Pizza Comparison — Hollywood, FL
Pepe's Neapolitan Pizza on Sheridan St is a quality option, but Mad Pizza offers a different style, better value, and wider delivery in Hollywood, FL.
| Mad Pizza | Pepe's Neapolitan Pizza | |
|---|---|---|
| Google Rating | 4.9 ★ | 4.5 ★ |
| Style | Chicago Thin-Crust | Neapolitan Pizza |
| Type | Family-Owned | Neapolitan Pizzeria |
| Price Range | $$ | $$$ |
| Mozzarella | Hand-Shredded Daily | Standard |
| Sauce | Sicilian Family Recipe | Standard |
| Delivery | Fast — 10+ Areas | Limited |
| Signature Dishes | Mad Meatballs, Italian Beef | Standard Menu |
More affordable pricing ($$ vs $$$)
Higher Google rating (4.9 vs 4.5)
Wider delivery area — Pepe's is primarily dine-in
Unique Chicago thin-crust vs Neapolitan style
Broader menu with Italian specialties
Fast delivery across Hollywood & surrounding areas
Family-owned with Sicilian heritage recipes
Pepe's serves authentic Neapolitan-style pies — smaller, wood-fired, and at a premium price point. Mad Pizza takes a different approach with Chicago thin-crust: a razor-thin crunch, generous toppings, and portions that deliver real value. Our hand-shredded mozzarella and slow-simmered Sicilian sauce are made fresh daily, and our 4.9-star Google rating edges out Pepe's 4.5. Plus, Mad Pizza delivers fast across Hollywood, Hollywood Beach, Hallandale, and beyond — while Pepe's is primarily a dine-in experience.
Both are quality pizzerias, but Mad Pizza offers better value, wider delivery, and a unique Chicago thin-crust style that stands out in Hollywood, FL.
Order from Mad Pizza — fast delivery, fresh ingredients, 4.9-star rated.