Our sauce is made fresh every day, and the process is one of the most important routines in our kitchen.
Selecting the Tomatoes
Not all canned tomatoes are equal. We use high-quality whole tomatoes that have been picked at peak ripeness and processed quickly to preserve their natural flavor. The variety and quality of the tomatoes determine the foundation of the sauce, so we never compromise here.
The Aromatics
Fresh garlic is a non-negotiable component. We use real garlic, not garlic powder or pre-minced garlic in a jar. The garlic is prepared fresh and added at a specific point in the cooking process to release its flavor without burning.
The Herb Blend
Our 4-generation recipe includes a specific blend of dried and fresh herbs that we do not publicly detail. What we can say is that the blend has been refined over decades to achieve a balanced, complex flavor that does not lean too heavily on any single herb. Oregano, basil, and other Italian herbs play roles.
The Simmering Process
Our sauce simmers on the stove, allowing the flavors to meld and the sauce to reduce to the right consistency. Quick-cooked sauces lack the depth that simmering creates. The heat transforms the raw tomato flavor into something richer and more complex.
Seasoning and Adjusting
Every batch is tasted and adjusted before it goes onto pizzas. Natural variations in tomatoes mean that small adjustments to salt and seasoning keep the final product consistent. Our kitchen team knows the target flavor profile and fine-tunes each batch to match.
Why It Matters
When you bite into a slice of Mad Pizza, the sauce is the first flavor that hits. It needs to be bright enough to wake up your palate, savory enough to satisfy, and balanced enough to complement the hand-shredded mozzarella and crispy crust without overwhelming them.
Taste our daily sauce at 211 N 21st Ave in Hollywood, FL. Call (754) 275-8466 to order.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Mad Pizza make their sauce in-house?
Yes, we make our pizza sauce from scratch every day in our kitchen using our 4-generation family recipe. No pre-made, jarred, or supplier-provided sauce is used.
What is in Mad Pizza's sauce?
While we keep the exact recipe private, our sauce is made with high-quality tomatoes, fresh garlic, a blend of Italian herbs, and seasonings following a recipe passed down through four generations.
Is Mad Pizza's sauce recipe a secret?
The specific recipe is a closely guarded family formula passed through four generations. We can share that it uses quality tomatoes, fresh garlic, Italian herbs, and a simmering process that develops deep flavor.
Ready to Taste the Difference?
Order authentic Chicago thin-crust pizza from Mad Pizza. Every slice supports veterans through our LEGION partnership.